The Majestic Food Market, Butler

| Paul Havemann

This lovely calendar page is from 1915. I had not previously heard of the Imwolde Brothers, nor of the market they ran. What’s their story?

The Old Newspapers don’t reveal a lot. Herman & Henry Imwolde immigrated from Germany in the early 1900s and opened a shop on Main Street which they called “The Majestic Food Market” – a grocery and butcher store.

Inez Farrel probably worked there, too. She must have liked it, and she surely like Henry, because she married him in 1915.

The shop was somewhere on Main Street. Perhaps it’s in this 1912 photo?

This 1914 account of an unfortunate incident involving spooked horses offers a clue.

“The frightened horses ran down Main street toward Maycock’s bridge…” Well. Anyone in town knows which way is “down” Main Street, and that’s toward Bloomingdale. But “Maycock’s bridge” is new to me. It’s obviously the one that led you over the river to Union Square. Was he a landowner? Bridge builder? Anyway, I deduce the shop might have been on lower Main Street.

The calendar page above featured this on the reverse. The Imwoldes were rightly proud of their store. I’m pretty sure that the attractive girl on the postcard was not Mrs. Imwolde.

Business, and life, must have been good to the family. Inez’s father John Farrel was, at one time, the mayor of Butler. He made a living selling paper boxes. The occasion of the Farrels’ 50th anniversary required a family dinner at the Norton Inn (which is another post that I promise to write). As it happened, Henry and Inez celebrated their tenth anniversary at the same time. Dinner was followed by a reception at Henry’s summer cottage on Glenwild Lake. Yes, life was good.

For those who may be inclined toward researching family histories, the Farrels had two daughters besides Inez – Mrs. Joseph I. Simpson and Mrs. Edward Rodda. All lived in Butler. Two young grandchildren were named in the anniversary article: Lavorra Rodda and John Simpson.

I could find no news about Henry’s brother Herman, not in the Old Newspapers and not on the Ancestry website. There is one who lived in Passaic around this time, but old city directories yield few details. We might never know.

I haven’t found much more to this story. At some point Henry would have retired and/or sold the shop, leaving only a few footprints in Butler’s history. Henry died in 1975, and Inez followed in 1983, having lived in Butler all her life.

If you, dear reader, have anything to add to this tale, kindly leave a comment.

-30-

How Sherman Avenue Got Its Name

| Paul Havemann

Ever wonder how Sherman Avenue, off the Boulevard in Pompton Plains, got its name? It was one of several roads built during the township’s expansion that began in the 1870s thanks to the new railroad. This photo is from about 1915 when the street was fairly new, unpaved, and not yet cluttered with houses.

Sherman Avenue, about 1915

The street was named for a real estate agent, George W. Sherman, who created a subdivision about 1910 on both sides of Sherman and the south side of Hopper Ave. He billed himself as “the largest real estate dealer in North Jersey.”

Portion of the 1915 tax map of Pequannock Township

Then as now, there was plenty to like about Pompton Plains. A closer look at the ad, below, boasts that “The land is all level, high and dry; no malaria; no damp sea air; the healthiest location in North Jersey.” But wait, there was more: “Sunshine and fresh air [and] pure, sparkling water.”

A 1909 ad for Sherman’s building lots in Pompton Plains NJ

Buyers would also enjoy “Gorgeous Mountain Scenery, fine churches, schools, stores, etc.” and it was all “Only five minutes’ walk to the station”.

Anyone have photos of their homes on Sherman, or elsewhere in Pequannock Township, from back in the day? Leave a comment!

Thanks to Jay Wanczyk for contributing to this entry.

-30-

The ‘Ghost Bridge’ of Oak Ridge Reservoir – Part 3

| Paul Havemann

(Part One … Part Two)

I’ve always wondered what the original, long-gone village of Oak Ridge was like before it was covered by the waters of the reservoir. There are hints in vintage letters and postcards, as well as in tales told by the descendants of those who lived there. If there are old photos, I have yet to find them.

This photo offers a glimpse of the original Oak Ridge village. Taken in 1965, it’s an aerial view of the reservoir, showing long-drowned roadways. If you think 2024’s drought is bad, this was worse. The 1960s drought, which occurred from late 1962 to 1966, was deemed the most severe drought in the northeast United States over the last century [cite].

The Oak Ridge Reservoir in 1965. Click for full-sized photo.

In this photo, the view is looking the south/southeast. The Pequannock River enters the valley at lower right, meandering its way along the bed. Route 23 is at the bottom… those small rectangles are cars on the highway. Unfortunately, the ghost bridge is just outside this photo. You can, however, see a number of roadways heading north/south and east/west – something I did not see on my early-November visit. The small hamlet of Wallace Corner is probably not in this photo either, but you can see the road(s) that would have taken you there.

You can also see – right above Route 23 – the original path of the Paterson-Hamburg Turnpike (as discussed here).

Should you choose to visit this 19th-Century artifact, know that the Newark Watershed has regular patrols of the area. In fact, in November 2024, the West Milford police were actively ticketing visitors for trespassing.

-30-

The Great Railroad Sign Caper of 1940 – 3

| Paul Havemann

The third of three “Then & Now” photos I acquired a while back (here’s the first one and here’s the second).

To quote the earlier posts, the origin of these is as interesting as their content: In 1940, someone stole the black-and-yellow “Railroad Crossing” signs at the two Butler crossings on the Paterson-Hamburg Turnpike. An employee of the NYS&W (New York Susquehanna & Western) railroad was sent to document the scene. Were the vandals caught? Doubtful. The signs were, however, replaced.

In this one, we’ve made a U-turn and are driving south. Between the two railroad crossings stands the venerable old business known then, as now, as Excelsior Lumber.

Click the photo to see it full size. There are interesting details to see.

The full size photo is a real glimpse into the past. Look closely, and you’ll see that there was a railroad siding that ran behind the yard. The car is a late 1930s something (suggestions welcome).

At right is a Sunoco gas station. There are two gasoline pumps sporting glowing globes on top. The car appears to be 1920s. you can see the fellow who pumped the gas chatting with someone in the dump truck. The building was expanded into a full-service garage at some point, but the gas pumps are long gone.

Visible above the tree line is the original, really tall smokestack of the Pequannock Valley Paper Company (about half was removed when the mill closed). And straight ahead, just over the RR tracks, is a RR siding building that we saw in the first photo.

Here’s how this scene looks today.

What became of the classic black-and-orange signs? They probably graced the wall of the thieves’ garage or rec room. Were they ever caught? Was the theft responsible for an accident? I did not find any mention in the old newspapers; perhaps a railroad buff might know more.

And that’s our tour! If you enjoyed the drive, I hope you’ll let me know in the comments.

-30-

The Great Railroad Sign Caper of 1940 – 2

| Paul Havemann

The second of three “Then & Now” photos I acquired a while back (here’s the first one).

The origin of these is as interesting as their content: In 1940, someone stole the black-and-yellow “Railroad Crossing” signs at the two Butler crossings on the Paterson-Hamburg Turnpike. An employee of the NYS&W (New York Susquehanna & Western) railroad was sent to document the scene. Were the vandals caught? Doubtful. The signs were, however, replaced.

This 1940 view shows the Paterson-Hamburg Turnpike approaching the second RR crossing as you head north, just past Maple Lake Road. The house in the distance was the Smith general store back when the area was known as Smith Mills.

Click on the photo to see it full size.

The old iron bridge ahead was replaced in 2010. Just beyond it is the building once known as the old Smith general store, still standing, as can be seen in the 2019 Google street view.

Here’s a street view of the same scene today. Feel free to drive along. Many more trees now, so the Smith store is just about visible.

And now, we’ll make a U-turn and take a better look at that lumber yard – and the gas station across the street.

-30-

The Great Railroad Sign Caper of 1940 – 1

| Paul Havemann

Who doesn’t like “Then & Now” photos? I have some to share which have never been seen before. The origin of these is as interesting as their content: In 1940, someone stole the black-and-yellow “Railroad Crossing” signs at the two Butler crossings on the Paterson-Hamburg Turnpike. An employee of the NYS&W (New York Susquehanna & Western) railroad was sent to document the scene. Were the vandals caught? Doubtful. The signs were, however, replaced.

This 1940 view shows the Paterson-Hamburg Turnpike approaching the first RR crossing as you head north; just around the bend lies Excelsior Lumber – the same company that is still there today. (The history of the company is interesting!) The building at right, at 160 Hamburg Turnpike, has been replaced by a much larger one.

Click the photo to view it full sized.

If you look closely, above the roadside railing, are houses on Apshawa Cross Road. (There are a lot more trees now than there were then.)

Here’s a street view of the same scene today. Feel free to drive along. Note the railroad siding at far right. It was used for the lumber yard as well as for the Pequannock Valley Paper Company, which was – and still is – behind us.

Let’s head down the road to the next view from 1940. We’ll see more of the Excelsior Lumber company in the third photo.

-30-

Butler Business Center – 1950

| Paul Havemann

Here are two views of the stores and merchants populating Main Street in Butler NJ, on a fine Spring day in March 1950. At that time it was a quiet factory town – the devastating fire that would destroy the borough’s largest employer, the Pequanoc Rubber Company, was still seven years into the future.

There’s a lot to examine in these two photos. In the first, taken from Park Place, shows the hulking three-story American Stores Company (Acme) next to Kadish Drugs. The much-beloved Nees Bakery (and other stores) are remembered to this day.

By clicking on the photo, you’ll open a new tab with the full-sized image.

If you chose to stroll up the street, you’d pass Romano’s Market, the Acme, and Kadish Drug Store. You might be tempted by the mouth-watering odors wafting from the open door of Nees Bakery. Further up, you’d pass Louis Levine’s fine furniture store, the Butler News Company, and a variety of others. At F.B. Whittle’s Hardware, you could pick up just about anything you’d need for around the home or garden. Across the street, you might see a train pulling into the Butler depot. Beyond Tintle and DePuyt Taxi Service, a ways up, you’d see the Pequanoc Soft Rubber Mill with its 225-foot smokestack. Just past Harry and Joe’s Cut Rate Meat Market, you could, if you wished, get a room at F.R. Casterlin’s Park Hotel and Stables – at one time it was known from one end of the East to the other – or just have a meal at their well-stocked bar & grill. Truly, uptown had just about anything you might need.

But wait – you haven’t seen what’s down Main Street the other way yet.

By clicking on the photo, you’ll open a new tab with the full-sized image.

At extreme left there appears to be a variety store (“$1.00 and up”). This side of the liquor store and Butler House (rooms to let) you could get your shoes repaired. After the Safeway is Claude Post’s radio and television sales and repair shop. (Those things were heavy, so he would send a repairman to take it back to the shop.) You’d stroll past Tice Hardware, Pink’s drug store, the Brass Rail (where you might wet your whistle with a beer), and more.

Down around the bend you’d spot Butler Coal & Lumber, across the street by the tracks, before arriving at Martin Cook’s Riverside Hotel. If you chose to go further, you’d find yourself at the Butler Argus building, where the next edition was being readied for printing. After that, you’d find yourself crossing the bridge into Union Square… but that’s another post.

If you’ve enjoyed this trip down memory lane, why not let me know? And credit is due to the Butler Museum, which is housed in the historic, brick-red New York, Susquehanna and Western railroad station. Many of the stores listed came from their do-it-yourself tour of Butler, using their Museum Historic Address Highlights page. The museum is well worth a visit.

Finally, as you might note, parking along Main Street was something of an issue then. The newly-formed Butler Business Men’s Association would meet (the same week as these photos, coincidentally) to discuss possible solutions.

Today, there’s parking on both sides from Park Place on up – but that wasn’t possible until the second set of tracks was removed at some point.

-30-

The Tri-Angle Lodge, Newfoundland

| Paul Havemann

The Tri-Angle Lodge stood “2 miles West of Newfoundland NJ,” according to the postcard. The building, which still stands, is on the north side of Route 23 at Canistear Road.

The Lodge was owned and operated by the Arrouge family who owned it from about 1928 until the early 1960s. Gertrude Pittenger (or Pettinger) Arrouge and her son, Dwight, ran it day to day. Some locals still remember walking to the Lodge in their youth to purchase candy, gum, or cigarettes.

The Tri-Angle Lodge in the 1930s. Note the Texaco gas pump at right.

You could also fill your tank up your car with genuine Texaco gasoline. Some remember serenading Dwight with the Texaco jingle when a car would pull up.

The 1950 Census shows Gertrude Arrouge living there with her daughter Joan, Joan’s son, and two lodgers named Card. (Gert’s husband, Emil, died in 1931.)

The Lodge also offered “home cooking” for the hungry, including sandwiches and chicken dinners. You could even hire them to host a dinner party. If you just wanted a snack, you could use the walk-up window.

Evidently known both as “Triangle” and “Tri-Angle”, the Lodge offered “refreshments of all kinds.”

Interestingly, Gertrude’s father, Warren Pettinger, was a “dowser” – a person who could locate water with only a Y-shaped tree branch. A newspaper article, published shortly before he died in 1947, noted that he claimed to have dowsed for – and located – water sources 328 times.

The Lodge building is still there, known as the Razor Tune Ski Shop. It still looks much the same, but has no connection to its countryside past.

-30-

Jasper Cropsey’s Wondrous Pompton Valley

| Paul Havemann

“Pompton Plains, New Jersey” is a famous painting by Jasper Francis Cropsey from about 1867.

Opinions differ on just where Mr. Cropsey placed himself while painting this wonderful view of the Pompton Valley. (Maybe if you could find that boulder…) You can see the Pompton River in the foreground; some speculate that the Morris Canal feeder dam lay just beyond the bend.

But if you look closely, right there in the center, is the First Reformed Church of Pompton Plains. (I’ve written about this church before.)

Do you see it? It’s way off in the distance. If you need a hint, here you go. (You can also click on the image above to see it vastly enlarged.)

We modern folk need to keep in mind that, in the 19th Century, the Pompton Valley was pretty empty. There were few buildings, and vast portions weren’t covered by trees as is the case today.

Other buildings in Cropsey’s painting may be identified. For example, this one – to the right of the church – appears to show the Martin Berry House and a barn in front of it. Look for the gap between the mountains in the full-sized image.

Since we know where the church is, it may be possible to identify some of the buildings on either side from other sources.

“Pompton Plains, New Jersey” may be seen at the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

Pequannock County?

| Paul Havemann

There was a time when the people of Bloomingdale, which at that time included the north end of Riverdale (“East Bloomingdale”) and most of Butler (“West Bloomingdale”), desired to form a new county. They envisioned taking parts of five counties to form “Pequannock County” — with Bloomingdale as the county seat, of course.

This effort failed, but ultimately Bloomingdale would become an independent borough when Pompton Township was broken up in 1918.

A companion article in the same 1879 newspaper explained why Bloomingdale anticipated a bright future accompanied by both industrial and residential growth.